Catch Rate and Other Stats I Hate This is the 7th in a series of articles

[panxing18]

I am writing to analyze some common NFL statistics http://www.coltsauthorizedshops.com/aut ... ant-jersey , focusing on how much value they have relative to team wins. I want to acknowledge the work of Brian Burke, Chase Stuart, and even our own Matt Grecco, who inspired this analysis and whose methodologies I have leveraged, as well as Pro Football Reference, Armchair Analysis, NFL.com and the nflSCrapR project as the sources of my data.I’ll start with a quiz. Since 2000, which Tight End with at least 75 career targets has the highest catch rate?A) Tony GonzalezB) Antonio GatesC) Rob GronkowskiD) Jimmy GrahamE) Some TE whose last name does not begin with “G”If you chose “E”, congratulations, you are correct. Catching 77% of all passes thrown his way, the TE with the highest catch rate this century is . . . Jack Doyle. In fact, no need to limit it to TEs, he has a catch rate higher than any wide receiver.That’s right, Doyle rules catch rate. Unfortunately, he also rules a crap stat.In a perfect world, where all things are equal, I would have no problem with catch rate, but we don’t live in that world. Instead, we live in a murky, shadow world, where Sense8 warranted a second season and people happily cheer for the Patriots. And in that world, variables beyond a receiver’s control impact his catch rate. Now, to be fair, all stats suffer from similar “noise”, but catch rate (CR) is particularly susceptible. WINSBecause CR is such a noisy stat, it doesn’t even clear the simple threshold of being moderately related to wins and if a stat isn’t measuring a skill that leads to wins then what is the point? You might as well just track who wins the opening coin toss . . . which I do. If you read my post on passer rating, then the following data won’t be new to you. Receiving yards, yards per catch and catch rate aren’t very good stats because they aren’t good descriptors of how games are won (low correlation to wins).Of course, those are the 3 most common receiving metrics in use today, so there’s that (#shadow_world). On the other hand, Yards Per Target (YPT), which is just receiving yards divided by the number of targets (attempts) is a good stat, but let’s put a pin in that for now. QB NOISEQBs have variable skill levels and develop different relationships with their receivers that impact CR. Here is a sample of receivers who had at least 100 targets with 2 different QBs. Catch Rate by QBPlayerQBCmpAttCatch RateDifferencePlayerQBCmpAttCatch RateDifferenceThose are some big, cherry-picked-to-make-a-point, differences. There is probably a lot going on there outside of just the QB, but you get the idea. Without a change in skill, the same receiver can have very different CR numbers under different QBs. The mere fact that QBs have varying completion rates is evidence of that.In 2017, Drew Brees completed 72% of his passes while DeShone Kizer notched less than 54%. AIR YARD NOISEBut perhaps the biggest confounding factor of CR is how each receiver is used. Is he running deep routes or is he primarily a check down? This takes us into the realm of air yards Cheap Jordan Wilkins Jersey , which is the total distance that a football is thrown past (or short of) the line of scrimmage to the point of reception (or where the reception would have been if incomplete). The following chart breaks out average NFL catch rate by air yards (aY). Clearly, length matters. Uh, phrasingThere is a near perfect linear drop-off in CR the further down the field the receiver is. In fact, the relationship is so strong that statistically speaking, around 98% of the average catch rate is explained by air yards (1), leaving only 2% for other factors . . . like ball pressure (#shadow_world).Divide a receiver’s total air yards by the number of times he was targeted and you get what we stat nerds call the average depth of target (aDOT). In simpler language, it is the receiver’s average route depth on plays where he is targeted. I only have air yard data going back to 2009, but since then, of the top 50 TEs by targets, Doyle ranks #1 in catch rate but dead last in average depth of target (4.7yds). That is not a coincidence.He has a high catch rate because he catches short passes. ALTERNATIVESThe bottom line is catch rate is a bad stat and it can’t be used to compare receivers.So, is there a good receiving stat? Well, there’s good news and bad news.Remember YPT? <imagine the sound of one item being unpinned>.The good news is that yards per target explains wins very well (high correlation) and is predictive of wins. Also, since YPT is just yards per catch multiplied by CR (YPT = rYds/Ctch * Ctch/Tgt),it encompasses all the information of CR as well.Ironically, combining two not so good stats make a single good one (Oooh mathemagic).The bad news is that YPT it is heavily biased by air yards.When comparing YPTs,Doyle’s wee 6.56 pales in comparison to Gronk’s massive 9.93, primarily because Gronk’s aDOT is about 6 yards longer.Seriously, are we not doing phrasing anymore?And it gets worse. Receiving yards can be deconstructed into completed air yards and total yards after the catch:rYds = cmp_aY + ttl_YACAnd just like catch rate, YAC is also dependent on air yards, as illustrated below. It’s not a linear function like CR, but YAC is clearly not just receiver skill. My guess is that this represents defensive choke-points about 10 yards downfield, but that is an analysis for another day.So, while YPT is a good stat to measure a receiver’s impact on wins, it is still not something you can use to compare them directly.Frankly, I don’t believe you can legitimately compare receivers with any of the standard receiving stats. There are just too many variables. However, there’s nothing stopping me fromcreating my own rating stat. EXPECTATIONSWhat follows is a fun exercise (yes this is fun for me) demonstrating how a comparison stat could be made. I’ll apologize up front because this section is going to get a bit mathy.For the algebraic milksops, you should skip to the results section. Okay, are all the wussies gone? If you look back at the CR chart, you’ll notice Doyle’s 4.7 aDOT equates to an NFL average CR of about 71%, which he is outperforming (77%). Using regressions, I can calculate CR and YAC for each receiver given the air yards of their targets. Then I just use those expected values to adjust an existing stat and determine a performance over expectations. And since CR is a crap stat, I will use YPT.I showed you earlier that YPT is just CR multiplied by receiving yards per catch:YPT = CR * rYds / Ctch and also that total receiving yards can be deconstructed into completed air yards and total YAC:YPT = CR * ( cmp_aY + ttl_YAC)/ Ctch And since total YAC per catch is just YAC then: YPT = CR * (cmp_aY/Ctch + YAC) And if I swap actual values with expected values, then it becomes expected YPT:xYPT = xCR * (cmp_aY/Ctch + xYAC)And finally, the difference between actual YPT and expected YPT is YPT over expectations:YPToe = YPT - xCR *(cmp_aY/Ctch + xYAC)For the expected data, I used equations other than the trend lines in the graphs(2) to calculate xCR and xYAC, but Doyle’s numbers look like this: YPToe = 6.56 - 63.9% * (723 / 174 + 5.0)That comes to 0.68 which is a measure of how many more yards than expected he is producing with every ball thrown his way(3).And since YPToe uses air yards as a variable that number can be directly compared to other receivers.RESULTSIf this is a stat that actually captures a player skill that is related to wins and not already captured by standard YPT, then the correlation to wins (especially predictive correlation) should increase. And it does.So, after crunching all of those numbers Margus Hunt Jersey , I finally have an apples to some-other-fruit-that-is-closer-to-apples-than-it-was-before-all-of-this comparison of receivers.However, this is a rough draft of a stat, so treat this as more chainsaw than scalpel.Taking the 50 top TEs and 50 top WRs by targets since 2009, here are the top 10 players in YPToe. Top 10 YPToePlayerCmpAttpYYACcmp_aYaY/Cttl aYaDOTCRxCRYACxYACYPAxYPAYPAoePlayerCmpAttpYYACcmp_aYaY/Cttl aYaDOTCRxCRYACxYACYPAxYPAYPAoeOf the 50 TEs, Doyle ranks 43rd in standard YPT, but improves to 11th place using YPToe.TY Hilton has the opposite journey. His YPT ranks 5th among WRs, but drops a few spots to 9th in YPToe. Adding in running backs, here are the Colts receivers numbers for 2017 (at least 30 targets). Negative YPToe numbers indicate a receiver who did worse than expected . Colts 2017playerCmpAttpYYACcmp_aYaY/CaYaDOTCRxCRYACxYACYPAxYPAYPAoeplayerCmpAttpYYACcmp_aYaY/CaYaDOTCRxCRYACxYACYPAxYPAYPAoeAnd here are all teams ranked by their 2017 receiver’s weighted YPToe(4). Robert Woods, Todd Gurley and Cooper Kupp all had very strong results leading the Rams to a #1 spot. FOOTNOTES1) R-squared of 0.9835 for linear regression of league average catch rate by air yards for attempts between 1 and 30 yards. This strictly linear trend does not extend to shorter or longer passes and have been excluded for illustrative purposes.2)All regressions utilized individual play data and not the averages displayed in the charts. The dependent variable for CR is aDOT as that includes all passes but for YAC only completions matter and so avg completed air yards was used. The trend lines do not display a universal trend and so they were broken into separate ranges to better fit the data. The CR trend had 4 ranges:<0 aDOT (positive linear), 0 aDOT (point estimate), 1 - 30 aDOT (negative linear) and >30 aDOT (negative linear). For YAC, 3 different ranges applied:<-5 (pos. linear), -4 to 25 (cubic) and >25(neg linear). 3) One additional adjustment I made was to account for QB accuracy.Receivers of highly accurate QBs (Brees, Rodgers) should be penalized a bit and receivers of the Gabbert/Sanchez persuasion should get a bump.I didn’t go into the math here, but using a similar methodology of completion rate over expectations, I created a weighted QB adjustment for each receivers’s xCR before calculating his final xYPT. 4) Receivers with less than 30 targets were assigned a YPToe of 0.YPToe for each receiver was multiplied by attempts and totaled to get a team YPToe. This was then divided by team attempts to get a weighted avg YPToe.SBCL: At times, Andrew Luck worried he may never play football again Colts' Andrew Luck had moments of doubt about playing againAndrew Luck is feeling healthy, but he admits that he had moments in rehab when he wondered if he'd play again.After 585 days, Andrew Luck ready to goAndrew Luck: "There were one or two moments where I wondered if, ‘Am I ever going to be able to do this again?’”Andrew Luck Giddy About Returning To Game Action Thursday Night | 1070 the FanHow did Andrew Luck perform at Tuesday’s practice and how excited is he for Thursday’s preseason opener?Andrew Luck on return vs. Seattle: ‘I’m sure I’ll be nervous’ | CBS 4 - Indianapolis News, Weather, Traffic and Sports | WTTVWESTFIELD, Ind. – The smile is impossible to miss, and the result of knowing milestones have been faced and cleared over the past 20 months. He’s noticeably upbeat and energetic, and admittedly more appreciative of being able to once again play a kid’s game.Frank Reich Seeing Unique Rapport Between Andrew Luck, T.Y. Hilton | 1070 the FanThe duo of Andrew Luck and T.Y. Hilton looks like they’ve picked up right where they left off after not throwing to each other in 19 months.Colts Training Camp Notebook: Clayton Geathers Takes Part In Team Drills | 1070 the FanTuesday was the 11th day of practice for the Colts. What were the takeaways from the Colts’ 11th practice of Training Camp at Grand Park?Kenny Moore putting pressure on Quincy Wilson in Colts campIndianapolis Colts cornerback Kenny Moore II, a former undrafted free agent, is making plays in training camp.Denico Autry Feels Unleashed In Colts’ New DefenseNew Indianapolis Colts defensive tackle Denico Autry is ready to get disruptive in this new defense, which will be his first opportunity to show what he can do as a full-time starter.Steady Grant earning Colts' trust | Sports | heraldbulletin.comBack in his days as a wideout for Tulane, Ryan Grant looked up to Colts star Reggie Wayne.Colts would turn down a first-round pick for Jacoby Brissett? - Indianapolis Colts Blog- ESPNOwner Jim Irsay isn't just blowing smoke when he says "we think he's that good." His coaching staff considers Andrew Luck's backup a top-20 QB.2018 #ColtsCamp Notebook, Day 11: Colts Put In Final Preparations For SeahawksTuesday, Aug. 7, was the 11th practice day of the 2018 training camp for the Indianapolis Colts. What were some takeaways from the session?Colts Notebook: Depth chart competition continuesIndianapolis Colts open NFL preseason in Seattle with new look, Luck.The overhauled Indianapolis Colts sound, look much improved from year ago, and not just because quarterback Andrew Luck returns from shoulder surgery.Retired Jack Mewhort: ‘I’m Excited To See What The Future Holds’Despite experiencing a plethora of injury issues his first four seasons in the NFL, Jack Mewhort got a chance to give it a go with the Indianapolis Colts once again in 2018. He talked on Tuesday about what ultimately led to his decision to retire from theTraining Camp Media